What does your coffee taste like?
Pick the symptom. Bitter usually means over-extracted, sour means under-extracted, and weak means the ratio is off. Fix one variable at a time.
Over-extraction. Too much dissolved out of the grounds.
- Grind one step coarser
- Drop water temperature toward 195 F
- Shorten the brew or steep time
Usually the roast or the heat, not the recipe.
- Try a lighter roast
- Take drip coffee off the hot plate
- Check the water is not boiling when it hits the grounds
Under-extraction. Not enough dissolved out of the grounds.
- Grind one step finer
- Raise water temperature toward 205 F
- Lengthen the brew or steep time
A ratio problem, not an extraction problem.
- Use more coffee: move toward 1:15
- Check your 'cup' is 5 oz, not 8
- Weigh the dose instead of scooping
Espresso fails faster and louder than any other method.
- Bitter shots: coarser grind, cooler, shorter
- Sour shots: finer grind, hotter, longer
- Spraying or gushing: fix the puck prep
Inconsistency is a measurement problem.
- Weigh coffee and water every brew
- Replace a blade grinder with a burr grinder
- Keep one variable log: change one thing at a time
All the fix guides
- Bitter Espresso: Why Shots Turn Harsh and How to Fix It
Bitter espresso usually means over-extraction: the grind is too fine, the shot runs too long, or the yield is too high. Fix the timing first.
- Espresso Channeling: How to Spot It and Stop It
Espresso channeling is water punching a fast path through the puck. It tastes sour and harsh at once, and puck prep fixes it, not grind.
- Over Extracted Coffee vs Under Extracted: The Fix Chart
Over extracted coffee tastes harsh and drying, under extracted tastes sharp and thin. Grind, heat, time and ratio move the cup either way.
- Sour Coffee: Why It Happens and How to Fix It Fast
Sour coffee is under-extracted: grind too coarse, water too cool, or brew too short. Push extraction further, one small step at a time.
- Why Is My Coffee Bitter? Causes and the Fastest Fixes
Bitter coffee is almost always over-extracted: grind too fine, water too hot, or brewed too long. Change one variable at a time.
The one rule of troubleshooting
Change one thing between brews. If you change the grind, the dose and the temperature at once, a better cup teaches you nothing. The usual order: get the dose right first, then adjust grind, then temperature, then time. Most bad coffee is fixed at step one or two.
The fix tree, printed
The free BrewChart Card has a bitter-vs-sour decision tree on the back: taste, follow the branch, fix the variable it names.